Get the app

The Short Rib Clause · Part 3

The Menu Archive

by Cliffhung Studio8 min read

"How do you know my name?" I asked.

There was a pause on the line, then the sound of a man setting something down too fast.

"It was on the call sheet," Dev Mehta said. "Kitchen staff, page four. Lena Park, braise. I'm sorry. That sounds creepy when I say it out loud."

"A little."

"Can we meet? Somewhere that isn't the restaurant. Somewhere that isn't my office either, honestly."

He picked the place. The Starlite on Western Avenue, open twenty-four hours, ten o'clock that night.

I almost didn't go.

The termination packet was still on my kitchen table, fanned out where I'd left it. The NDA. The release giving up any claim to "recipes developed on premises." The letter that said Vole & Vine had "documented" my attempt to steal its proprietary recipes.

$5,088.75 in final pay and vacation, sitting behind a signature line.

They'd given me five business days.

I put the whole packet in a manila folder and took it with me.

The Starlite was half empty. A cab driver ate eggs at the counter. Two nurses in scrubs split a slice of pie by the window.

Dev was already in the back booth. I recognized him from the kitchen, the wire glasses and the tablet. Tonight he had a laptop, a legal pad, two pens, a phone charger and a cup of coffee he hadn't touched.

He stood up when he saw me and hit his knee on the table.

"Ms. Park. Thank you. Sit, please. Do you want anything? I'll pay. I mean, the network won't, but I will."

"Lena is fine," I said. "Just coffee."

He sat back down and lined up his pens.

I'd spent nine years watching cooks get ready for a rush. I knew what over-prepared looked like. He had sticky tabs on the legal pad in three colors.

"Before anything," he said, "I should tell you I'm not supposed to be here."

"Okay."

"I'm a segment producer. Part of my job, the part nobody sees, is verification. If a host says something on camera as a fact, I check it. Dates, places, names. If he says his grandfather fished off Nantucket, I find the boat."

"And Grant said his mother made short ribs every Sunday in Dayton."

"In the 1980s," Dev said. "He said she created the dish. And he said he's served it at Vole & Vine since opening night in 2012."

He said the dates like he'd written them down a dozen times.

"Most of the time it checks out," he said. "Or it's close enough. People round things. I don't flag rounding."

"So why flag this?"

He looked at me for a second.

"Because of your face," he said. "When he said it. I was standing behind the B camera. You stopped moving. Everybody else on that line kept working, and you just stopped, with tongs in your hand."

I didn't remember that.

I believed him anyway.

"Then you went up to him after the cut," Dev said. "I couldn't hear what you said. I saw what he did."

The waitress came. I ordered coffee. Dev ordered a grilled cheese and then said, "Actually, no, sorry," and then said, "Actually, yes."

When she left, he turned the laptop toward me.

"I went home that night and pulled every Vole & Vine menu I could find."

There was a folder on the screen labeled VV_MENUS. Inside were dozens of files, each named with a date.

"The restaurant's old website had a menu page," he said. "They redesigned in 2019 and wiped it. But the old pages are saved on a public web archive. Snapshots, every few weeks, going back to before they opened."

He clicked the first one.

It was a menu I hadn't seen in years. Cream background, a little drawing of a vine. Vole & Vine, Opening Menu, October 2012.

"Opening night," Dev said.

I read it top to bottom.

Roasted bone marrow. Hamachi crudo. Duck breast with cherries. Hanger steak. A pork chop with apple mostarda.

No short ribs.

"Maybe they ran it as a special," I said. I don't know why I said it. I was there in 2017. I knew.

"I thought of that," Dev said. "So I didn't stop at the website."

He opened a second folder. FOOD BLOGS.

"Chicago had a lot of food bloggers back then. People who ate everywhere and photographed everything. Second City Plates. Chew on Chicago. A guy who called himself the Fork Inspector who reviewed every new opening in Lincoln Park."

He clicked through screenshots. Blurry photos of plates under warm restaurant light. Long posts. Comment sections.

"Opening week, 2012, the Fork Inspector went twice. He photographed the menu both times, including the specials board."

He zoomed in. A chalkboard, slightly crooked. Halibut. A mushroom risotto. A lamb neck special.

No short ribs.

"Here's 2013," Dev said. "Spring menu, summer menu, fall. Here's 2014. This one's my favorite."

It was a post from Chew on Chicago, dated February 2014. He'd highlighted one sentence in yellow.

"I wish Vole would put something braised on this menu. It's the middle of a Chicago winter and the heaviest thing here is a hanger steak."

I read it twice.

"Somebody asked him for a braise," I said. "In writing. In 2014."

"And he didn't make one," Dev said. "Not that year, and not the next."

The waitress set down my coffee. I didn't touch it.

Dev kept going. He went through 2015 and 2016 like he was reading off a ticket rail. Website snapshots. Blog photos. A local magazine's "Best Bites" list that mentioned the duck. A crowd-review site he'd screenshotted under a different name because he said he wasn't allowed to name it in any document.

Every menu was a little different. Dishes came and went.

The short ribs never appeared.

"I made a spreadsheet," he said, a little embarrassed. "Sixty-one menus, 2012 through the end of 2016. Website and third-party sources. Zero short ribs."

"And 2017?"

He took a breath.

"January 2017, nothing. February, nothing. March, nothing."

He clicked.

A website snapshot. The same vine drawing, slightly updated. Spring Menu.

Halfway down, between the duck and the pork chop, a new line.

Braised Short Ribs. Asian pear, scallion, crispy rice. $38.

The snapshot was dated April 12, 2017.

"There's a blog post the same week," Dev said. He opened it. Second City Plates, April 14, 2017. A photo of the dish I'd plated a thousand times. The glossy rib. The pear on top. The rice.

The headline said: VOLE GOES COZY.

"The blogger calls it new," Dev said. "She says the server told her it was 'Chef's newest creation.'"

I felt sick and very calm at the same time.

"When did you cook them for the staff?" Dev asked.

He didn't ask whether I had. He asked when.

I didn't have to think about it.

"March twentieth," I said. "2017. A Monday."

"You're sure?"

"My halmoni's eightieth birthday was the Saturday before. The whole family came to the church hall. She made the short ribs herself, two giant pots, and she made me stand next to her the whole morning and do the pear."

I could still see her hands. The grater. The juice running down her wrist.

"Monday was my turn for family meal at work," I said. "I was still thinking about it. So I made a batch her way. Big hotel pan, rice, kimchi on the side. The whole kitchen ate it."

"Was Grant there?"

"He came down from his office. He never came down for family meal. He ate two portions standing up. Then he asked me what was in the braise."

"What did you tell him?"

"Everything," I said. "I didn't think it was a secret. It was dinner."

Dev wrote something on the legal pad. A date. An arrow.

"Did anyone write the recipe down?"

"I did. A few weeks later Marco asked me to put it on a card for the station. I wrote it out by hand and somebody laminated it. Marco took it down the night I got fired."

Dev put down his pen.

"March twentieth," he said. "April twelfth."

"Three weeks," I said.

"Twenty-three days."

The nurses by the window were laughing about something. The cab driver paid and left. The grill hissed behind the counter.

Dev's grilled cheese arrived. He didn't look at it.

"So he lied about opening night," I said.

"On camera. For a show that tells people it's about where food really comes from." He rubbed his eyes under his glasses. "If he'd said 2017, I'd have had nothing. Five years late is a strange thing to round."

I opened the manila folder and slid the termination letter across to him.

He read it slowly. When he got to the word "documented," he tapped it once with his finger.

"Documented what?"

"I don't know. I've never taken anything home from that kitchen except my own knives."

"Did you sign anything?"

"No."

"Good." He handed it back. "Please don't. I'm not a lawyer. I just know that when somebody is in a hurry to make you sign, they're usually scared of what's on the other side of the deadline."

My phone buzzed on the table. Tasha.

He put your card in the trash. The laminated one. Marco had it in his pocket since Friday and Chef told him to throw it out. I took a picture first.

A photo came through. My own handwriting, creased down the middle. Braised Short Ribs. Vole & Vine, the heading said. Grease marks at the corners.

I turned the phone so Dev could see.

He went very still.

"He's cleaning up," he said.

"He's cleaning up after me."

Dev looked at the photo a long time. Then he looked at the spreadsheet. Then he looked back at me.

"Here's my problem," he said. "Everything I have is about Vole & Vine. I can prove he didn't serve it in 2012. I can prove it showed up in April 2017. If his lawyer is smart, they say fine, Chef got the dates wrong, his memory's fuzzy, but the dish is still his mother's."

"It isn't."

"I believe you. A network lawyer won't care what I believe."

He saved the file. He unplugged the charger.

Dev closed the laptop and asked, "A menu proves when he started selling it. Do you have anything that proves when your family started making it?"

Part 4 continues in the Cliffhung app — free

Pick up exactly where you stopped.

Get the app

No subscriptions. Every story has a price cap.

All parts
  1. Part 1: Sunday Ribs in DaytonFree
  2. Part 2: Final Paycheck, Conditions ApplyFree
  3. Part 3: The Menu ArchiveFree
  4. Part 4: PareIn the app
  5. Part 5: The CamcorderIn the app
  6. Part 6: Work for HireIn the app
  7. Part 7: Section 14(c)In the app
  8. Part 8: Disgruntled Former EmployeeIn the app
  9. Part 9: The Conference RoomIn the app
  10. Part 10: Credit Where It's DueIn the app
Report this part