Get the app

The Ramp on Larkspur Court · Part 3

Public Comment

by Cliffhung Studio9 min read

Kyle Brandt had stood on my porch last April with a cup of my coffee in his hand.

He'd been wearing that same gray fleece vest. He said the association was "digitizing the architectural records" and asked if I had anything from when Tommy built the ramp.

I went straight to the hall closet and got the folder for him.

I even apologized for the dust.

He brought it back eight days later and handed it to me on the same porch, smiling. "All squared away, neighbor."

I never opened it to check, because why would I?

I sat on the hallway floor until almost two in the morning with that folder in my lap. Simone had gone back down to her apartment before nine-thirty. I could hear her moving around down there for a while, and then the house went quiet.

The lumber receipts were there. So were the county permit and the railing quote from Haskins & Sons.

The approval letter was gone, and the man who'd taken it had smiled while he gave the folder back.

In the morning I called the management company, Crestline Community Services, and sat on hold for forty minutes listening to a flute play the same six notes. A young woman named Brianna finally picked up.

"I'm showing no architectural approval on file for 14 Larkspur Court," she said.

"There was a letter. The board signed it in 2019."

"Ma'am, I can only tell you what's in the system."

"Who put it in the system?"

She was quiet for a second. "The board uploaded the architectural archive last spring."

I thanked her. I always thank people. Tommy used to say I'd thank the man who robbed me if he held the door on his way out.

Ray called that night from Charlotte.

"Mom, you can't prove he took a piece of paper out of a folder."

"I know he did."

"Knowing isn't proving. You know what a lawyer costs? Just list the house. I'll fly down and help you pack."

"There's a meeting Thursday," I said. "I'm going."

He sighed the way his father used to sigh at me.

"Then please don't cry in front of those people."

The notice was taped inside the glass of the mailbox kiosk at the end of the street. LARKSPUR COURT HOA, REGULAR BOARD MEETING, THURSDAY 7 P.M., CLUBHOUSE. Public comment, three minutes per homeowner, sign-up required.

I'd lived on this street for twenty-two years and gone to maybe four meetings. Tommy went to all of them. He liked the free coffee and the arguing.

On Thursday afternoon I finished my route, parked the bus at the depot, and drove home to change into my good blue blouse. I wrote out what I wanted to say on five index cards and practiced it at the kitchen table with the oven timer set for three minutes.

I came in at two minutes and forty seconds, with time left over.

At six-thirty there was a knock on the inside door, the one at the top of the basement stairs.

Simone stood there in a navy cardigan, her hair pulled back tight.

"You're going to the meeting," she said. It wasn't really a question.

"I am."

"Would you mind if I came? I live under this roof too. I'd like to know who's running it."

I should have asked her why a woman who paid her rent by check on the first of every month and kept to herself cared about an HOA meeting.

I was just glad I wouldn't be walking in alone.

The clubhouse sits by the pool, a beige building with a vaulted ceiling and a coffee urn that has been leaking since 2016. Somebody had set out about forty folding chairs. Maybe twenty-five people were in them.

At the front was a long table with a paper tablecloth. Kyle sat in the middle with a laptop and a little stand-up sign that said PRESIDENT. On his left was Gary Tull from the corner lot, who mostly looked at his phone.

On his right sat Denise Kowalski.

I knew Denise a little. She'd been a bookkeeper for a plumbing supply company for thirty-one years and brought lemon bars to Tommy's funeral. She had a laptop open in front of her with a spreadsheet on it, and she had both hands folded on the table next to it like she was afraid to touch it.

I signed the comment sheet. I was the only name on it.

June Albright from number nine waved me over before I could sit down. She's in her seventies, and she has never once had a thought she didn't say out loud.

"Gloria, honey, have you seen this?"

She held out her phone.

It was the neighborhood group chat, Larkspur Neighbors, with a hundred and twelve members. At the top was a video Marcus Hale had posted the day the ramp came down.

I watched three seconds of it. It showed the crew, the pry bar, and me in the driveway holding my keys.

The caption said: When the HOA said FAFO and meant it.

Under it were crying-laughing faces, eleven of them from different people. One man had written, About time, that thing was an eyesore. Somebody else had written, She shoulda read her bylaws lol.

"I think it's awful," June said. "I didn't laugh. I want you to know I didn't laugh."

"Thank you, June."

I gave her phone back. My hands were steady and I was proud of that.

Marcus was in the back row with his arms crossed and his cap pulled low. When I looked at him he found something interesting about the floor.

Simone took a seat in the very last row, by the door. She had a small notebook on her knee.

Kyle called the meeting to order at 7:04. He approved the minutes, read a report about pool hours, and spent six minutes on trash can visibility from the street.

Then he looked at the sign-up sheet.

"Public comment. Looks like we've got one. Mrs. Mendes, come on up, neighbor."

There was a microphone on a stand in front of the table. I didn't need it, but I used it anyway.

Kyle laid his phone face-up on the tablecloth. I could see the timer from where I stood.

"My name is Gloria Mendes," I said. "I live at 14 Larkspur Court. I've lived there since 2002."

I looked down at my first card.

"In 2019, after his stroke, my husband Tommy built a wheelchair ramp to our front door. Before he cut one board, he submitted plans to this board. The board approved it in writing. Loretta Pruitt was president. Every member signed."

Somebody's chair creaked.

"On the fourteenth of this month, a crew from Brandt Groundworks tore that ramp off my house without warning. I was told I'd been fined every day for eight months. I never received a single notice. The association has had my correct address for twenty-two years. The fines total eleven thousand four hundred dollars. The association has put a lien on my house. My house is paid off."

I turned to my third card.

"I am asking the board to show me the notices it claims it sent. I am asking for a copy of the architectural file for my lot as it existed before last April. And I am asking..."

"Okay." Kyle leaned toward his own little microphone. "I'm going to stop you there."

I looked at the phone. It read 2:01.

"I have almost a minute left."

"This is a legal matter now, Mrs. Mendes. It's with the association's attorney. It isn't appropriate for open session." He gave the room a sad, patient smile, the kind you'd give a child who won't get out of the pool. "I understand you're emotional. Anybody would be. But we have a lot of business tonight."

A couple of people laughed under their breath.

My face went hot all the way to my ears.

"I'm not crying," I said. "I'm asking for documents."

"And you can put that in writing to Crestline. Thank you, neighbor."

He reached over and stopped the timer.

I looked at Denise. She was staring at her spreadsheet so hard I thought the screen might crack. Her pen was in her hand, and it hadn't moved.

I gathered my cards and walked back to my chair. My left knee picked that moment to lock up, and I had to catch the back of a folding chair to keep my balance. Nobody moved to help me.

Marcus stood halfway up in the back row, then sat down again.

"New business," Kyle said.

He tapped his laptop, and a projector on a cart lit up the wall behind him. The slide was white with big red letters.

EMERGENCY SPECIAL ASSESSMENT: RESERVE SHORTFALL. $1,800 PER LOT. DUE IN 60 DAYS.

The room woke up all at once.

"Eighteen hundred dollars?" said a man by the coffee urn.

"Folks, folks." Kyle held up both hands. "Nobody likes this. I don't like this. But the previous boards let a lot of deferred maintenance pile up. Storm drainage, mostly. We've been doing major mitigation work and the reserves took a hit. The board voted in executive session to protect the community."

"What drainage work?" June called out. "My yard floods same as always."

"It's mostly underground, June. You wouldn't see it."

I was barely listening to him anymore.

I was thinking about the shoebox on my closet shelf labeled HOA 2023. It held every newsletter, every pool pass, and every budget they'd mailed us.

I opened my purse. I'd brought the association folder with me, because I bring everything.

The 2023 annual budget was the third page down. It was one sheet, printed on both sides, with Denise's name at the bottom as treasurer.

Line 14 read: Reserve Fund, Balance as of September 30, 2022, $341,950.

I stood up. My knee complained and I ignored it.

"Mr. Brandt. Last year's budget shows three hundred forty-one thousand, nine hundred and fifty dollars in reserves. It's right here. Your treasurer signed it."

Every head in the room turned to look at Denise.

She went white. Her hand moved to her laptop and then away from it.

"Public comment is closed, Mrs. Mendes," Kyle said.

"Then I'm asking as a homeowner. Where did three hundred forty thousand dollars go in a year and a half?"

"The financials will be available to members through the proper process." His smile stayed in place, but something tight had come into his jaw. "Motion to adjourn?"

"So moved," Gary Tull said, without looking up from his phone.

"Second," Kyle said, and banged a little wooden gavel I'm fairly sure was a toy.

It was 7:41.

People filed out muttering. Several of them gave me a wide berth, the same way you'd steer around a spill. June squeezed my arm. Denise packed up her laptop so fast she left her charger plugged into the wall.

Kyle stayed at the front table, laughing about something with Gary.

Simone was waiting by the door with her notebook closed.

The parking lot was dark except for one buzzing light by the pool fence. My knee had stiffened up during the meeting, and Simone took my elbow without asking, the way you'd steady someone on a bus step.

We were halfway to my car before either of us said anything.

"You had your budget with you," she said.

"I keep everything."

"I noticed."

She waited until I'd unlocked the car door. Then she looked back once at the lit clubhouse windows, where Kyle was still standing in his fleece vest.

Walking me to the car, Simone asked quietly, "Mrs. Mendes, do you happen to know how much this association pays Brandt Groundworks?"

Part 4 continues in the Cliffhung app — free

Pick up exactly where you stopped.

Get the app

No subscriptions. Every story has a price cap.

All parts
  1. Part 1: Eleven Thousand Four HundredFree
  2. Part 2: The Shoebox WallFree
  3. Part 3: Public CommentFree
  4. Part 4: For the StateIn the app
  5. Part 5: Savannah Has CopiesIn the app
  6. Part 6: Savannah Has Copies, Part TwoIn the app
  7. Part 7: Reasonable AccommodationIn the app
  8. Part 8: Willow FordIn the app
  9. Part 9: The Lawyer Reads the FileIn the app
  10. Part 10: Annual MeetingIn the app
Report this part